As the days grow shorter and the cold winds howl, December is here and it ushers in the time for our roundup of the best in metal and dark folk for 2023. This year has been exceptional, particularly in genres like symphonic and power metal, and notably in debut releases.
In 2023, we’ve broadened our scope, introducing new genres and, for the first time, a category for best music video. This expansion is just the beginning; we plan to include even more categories and more next year. But, reflecting on the past year, we’ve witnessed a slew of amazing releases, some possibly marking the final echoes of the pandemic era.
Several record labels had standout years. Atomic Fire Records impressed us with a slew of enjoyable releases. Napalm Records, in particular, had a monumental year. Their dominance over our list is reminiscent of the ‘Great Century Media’ takeover a few years backs.
Not only did they release a high volume of content; their releases were consistently strong. Delain delivered an outstanding album, Gloryhammer arguably released their best work yet, and Lords of the Lost brought some genuinely entertaining music to the table.
Deciding our favorites this year was a challenging task for the staff, given the sheer quality and variety of releases. But, the list below will reveal which albums and artists who truly stood out to us in 2023.
Album Of The Year – We Shall Remain – Eleine
Eleine, with their latest offering “We Shall Remain,” has ascended to the top of our list as the Album of the Year, a position that seems almost inevitable given their consistent presence in our previous selections. Each new project from Eleine has seen them grow in our esteem, and this year, amidst a challenging competition for the best symphonic album, “We Shall Remain” emerged as an unparalleled favorite record of the year, period.
This album marks a venture into darker and more dare we say, catchy realms, a feat not easily achieved in dark symphonic music. Eleine manages to blend the shadowy with the catchy, creating an album that’s as haunting as it is a real headbanger. The band’s songwriting of course is a standout feature, infusing each track with profound emotion and depth.
While not strictly groove metal, incorporates groovy elements that add an irresistible rhythmic pull to the album. This aspect of their music adds an extra layer of appeal, showing that, hey, Eleine’s versatility and understanding of how to keep their sound both fresh and engaging is there.
At the heart of Eleine’s success is their authenticity and strong connection with their fans. The band writes music that’s true to themselves, which resonates deeply with their audience. This genuine approach to music-making is easily felt throughout the album. The duality in their music, with Rikard’s energizing presence there to make you headband, and the complementing Madeleine’s soothing vocals there to calm you down, continues to be a winning formula for the band. This dynamic has been a signature of Eleine’s sound and is brilliantly executed in “We Shall Remain.” This is an album from that has mastered their craft and continues to connect authentically with their fans.
Best Folk Metal Album – Lunar – Solarcycles
Solarcycles’ first full release, “Lunar,” is a monumental achievement that rightfully earns one of our top spots this year. This album showcases a band that has not only matured in their sound but has also stepped up in terms of production quality, resulting in a polished and all around great record.
The growth is not just in their production, but also in their songwriting and overall artistic direction. The album reflects a deeper understanding of their craft, and it’s great to see how far this band has come. This was a great year in Folk Metal, and Solarcycles stands on top.
Best Celtic Metal Album – The Living and The Dead – Cruachan
Cruachan, a band synonymous with the very foundations of folk metal, has delivered an extraordinary work with “The Living and The Dead.” This album, which might just be their magnum opus, is a great blend of the folk and metal elements that define their pioneering sound.
In “The Living and The Dead,” Cruachan delves deeper into the folk aspect of their music, enriching the album with a strong sense of tradition and cultural resonance. Yet, the essence of metal remains undiminished – the album is laced with the robust, heavy sound that fans have always cherished. The result is a record that is both dynamic and cohesive, capturing the spirit of both genres.
Best Heavy Metal Album – The Dark Tower – Burning Witches
This year has seen its fair share of standout heavy metal albums, but Burning Witches truly sets the bar high with their fifth studio release. Centered around the intriguing tales and historical accounts of ‘Countess Elizabeth Báthory’, this album stands out for its thematic cohesion and compelling storytelling. Though, not really a ‘concept’ album in the traditional sense.
Still, the album intertwines themes around this legendary figure, creating a great set of of songs that are both heavy on their own, and collectively powerful. The album also delivers of exceptional guitar work, delivering powerful riffs and solos with that classic heavy metal feel.
We also have to mention the amazing vocals of Laura Guldemond, which are truly a standout feature. Her voice brings a dynamic range and intensity to the album. Oh! And as an added bonus, the artwork is really awesome.
Best Pagan Folk Album – Carpe Noctem – Trobar De Morte
“Carpe Noctem,” the latest release from Trobar de Morte, arrived this past Samhain, adding a new jewel to their dark Pagan folk repertoire. Known for their mastery in this genre, the band continues their tradition of excellence with this album. It’s features tracks rich in atmosphere, maintaining the cinematic and ethereal qualities fans love. “Carpe Noctem” stands as a solid example to Trobar de Morte’s consistent growth and their skill in crafting immersive, dark folk melodies. An exceptional release, it underscores their status as a standout name in medieval folk.
Best Power Metal Album – At the Heart of Wintervale – Twilight Force
Twilight Force’s “At the Heart of Wintervale” is an impressive addition to the power metal genre, showcasing a blend of soaring vocals and exceptional production quality. This album stands out for its ability to deliver an over-the-top, metal experience that we’ve come to love so well.The album is a journey through a realm of high-energy riffs and memorable melodies. Each track is a display of Twilight Force’s skill in crafting songs that are catchy.
What makes “At the Heart of Wintervale” particularly enjoyable is its blend of intensity and melodiousness. The album strikes a perfect balance between the powerful drive of heavy metal and the epic, sweeping sounds that define power metal. This harmony creates an album that long-time fans of the genre and newcomers alike will love. It’s an album that satisfies the craving for heavy, energetic metal, while also providing a level of musicality and production quality that is chef’s kiss worthy.
Best Symphonic Metal Album – The Wonders Still Awaiting – Xandria
In the fiercely competitive arena that was this years symphonic metal scene, Xandria’s “The Wonders Still Awaiting” emerges as a jewel, hooking us in ways few albums have. We found the band weaving a world full of wonder that did not leave us waiting. We got a ton of great music from this record. And on another note, a lot of great videos as well.
Ambre Vourvahis’ vocal were a standout aspect of this album. Her voice dances across the symphonic backdrop, infusing each song with an air of elegance and power, and we got some great growls along the way. In a way, this album offered a fresh perspective on what the genre can be. Even from the artwork, to the amazing videos, this was a symphonic masterpiece.
Best Progressive Metal Album Exul – Ne Obliviscaris
Ok, this band is way too good. Ne Obliviscaris delivers another stellar addition to their discography with “Exul.” This record showcases the band’s continued evolution and reinforces their position as a benchmark in the genre. “Exul” hits hard with a deep sense of musical exploration and mastery. The band has woven a complex and coherent collection of tracks.
The album showcases an intricate balance between technical skill and expressive musicianship, a hallmark of Ne Obliviscaris’ approach to progressive metal. And we know that this is a band that’s always pushing the boundaries of their sound while maintaining a connection to their core musical identity. “Exul” is a remarkable album in progressive metal. Maybe even a new gold standard. The album shows off the band’s ongoing commitment to excellence and innovation in their work. It impresses with its technicality but also pulls you in with its emotive storytelling.
Best Debut Album – Imposter Syndrome – Sophie Lloyd
Sophie Lloyd’s “Imposter Syndrome” marks a striking debut this year. As you could probably tell, it’s a showcase of Lloyd’s guitar skills, enriched by a roster of special guests, each adding their unique touch to the mix. The album stands out for her skills of course, and its fusion of diverse styles.
The solos throughout the album are technically impressive and infused with emotion and energy that elevate each track. Lloyd’s ability to command the axe and use it to tell a story is evident in every song. It was a great listen from start to finish. Now, one might think, hey I just want the instrumentals, but the variety and quality of the collaborations on the album add to its dynamic nature.
Each guest brought something great to the table. Plus, this approach showcases Lloyd’s versatility and her ability to blend different influences into a cohesive sound. Sophie Lloyd brought an impressive showing, filled with great moments and big highlights.
Best Modern Metal Album -Chapter III – Downfall – Ad Infinitum
“Chapter III – Downfall” by Ad Infinitum was a massive standout the modern metal this year, offering a journey through ancient Egyptian mythology. The album shines with its strong songwriting and skilled guitar work, and of course, the over all theme. Ad Infinitum’s approach to blending historical themes with metal is always well executed.
What truly sets Ad Infinitum’s concept albums apart, including “Chapter III – Downfall,” is their balance between overarching themes and individual song craftsmanship. While each album follows a cohesive narrative, whether grounded in fact or fiction, the songs are composed in a way that allows them to shine independently. Each track is not only a part of a larger story but also stands strong on its own merit, open to various interpretations.
Best Black Metal Album – War Against All – Immortal
This latest album from Demonaz’s Immortal hits all the right notes for a classic black metal experience. It’s packed with the raw, unfiltered essence of Immortal’s signature sound, and yeah, it feels ‘current.’ The album embodies everything we crave in black metal: the intensity, the atmospheric depth, and that unmistakable Immortal touch. It’s a straightforward, no-nonsense record that delivers the goods, proving once again why Immortal remains a revered name in the genre.
Best Hard Rock Album – 666 – Cobra Spell
Cobra Spell’s debut album, “666,” really shakes up the heavy rock and metal scene this year, offering a high-octane ride back to the glory days of 80s sleaze hard rock. This album is like both a nod to the past and it’s a full-blown revival, packed with killer harmonies, infectious melodies, and guitar work that’s nothing short of outstanding. “666” has left a strong impression, proving that Cobra Spell is a band to watch. We loved their way of blending nostalgia with a fresh, energetic approach to the genre.
Best Pagan Metal Album – Kob’ – Arkona
In the folk metal scene, Arkona stands as a recurring name among the genre’s most iconic acts. Ask anyone to name their top five bands in that genre, and their name is likely to come up. Their latest release once again satisfies our craving for a blend of pagan folk and black metal, and this time around, they did go hard on the black metal side of things. Creatively, it might just be their most packed album to date. And when we say packed, it might actually feel compact at first glance, but yet it’s substantial. The album comprises only eight tracks but delivers a full hour of intense, engaging music, showcasing Arkona at what they do best.
Best Viking Metal Album – Ýdalir – Skálmöld
Skálmöld’s sixth studio release, “Ýdalir,” stands out as a formidable presence in the Viking metal genre. This album hits hard with an Icelandic intensity that’s unmistakably unique, and unmistakably Skálmöld. “Ýdalir” impressed us right from the start, but its true depth revealed itself over time, growing richer with each listen.
The album blends the melodic and the heaviness, which is something that will touch even the most brutal Viking metal heart. Whether you’re a casual listener or a hardcore fan, “Ýdalir” has something for you, and you really should check it out. Skálmöld has created an album that delivers just what we want in a Viking metal album.
Best Solo Project Album – 月虹創聖記 / Moonbow Genesis – Isiliel
Isiliel, the solo venture of Himari Tsukishiro, made a significant impact this year with the international version of “Moonbow Genesis.” This album, eagerly awaited by fans, exceeded expectations with its blend of originality and accessibility. In its first release, “Moonbow Genesis” captivated with ten compelling tracks, while the international version added even more value with bonus content, including an additional track and English translations of the songs.
The album stands out for its artistic depth and the most blend of various musical elements and traditional instruments. It showcases Isiliel’s talent for creating a sound that is both unique and how it can resonant with a global audience.
Earning its place as one of our favorite albums of the year, “Moonbow Genesis” is a perfect example of the creative vision and skill of Himari Tsukishiro as a solo artist. It’s a deserving choice for the Best Solo Project Album, reflecting a blend of innovation, musicality, and international appeal.
Most Innovative Metal Album – American Gothic – Wayfarer
Wayfarer’s “American Gothic” sets a new standard in the world of Western folk metal. This album stands as a masterful creation, showcasing the band’s ability to define and dominate the genre. And dominate, they have. Their approach to blending Western folk elements with metal is executed so, so well, setting a new direction for others in the subgenre to follow.
This record stands out for its innovative approach and the sheer amount of heavy western folk metal it offers. Wayfarer has not only created an album that pushes the boundaries but also one that is setting the bar into orbit to others in the subgenre. Haunting, heavy, and amazing.
Best Death Metal Album – Hymns From The Apocrypha – Suffocation
We might have gotten the perfect death metal record this year, folks. Suffocation’s “Hymns From The Apocrypha” marks a remarkable return for the band after six years, setting what many might see as a new benchmark in death metal. This release stands out for its sheer consistency and strength, with each track contributing to an undeniably great album. This was one of the most consistent and well-rounded albums we found this year, as all the tracks are great, and it made many of us rethink out top five DM albums.
Best Metal EP – Hagakure II – Bloody Tyrant
Taiwanese act Bloody Tyrant, with their EP “Hagakure II,” has set a high standard in melodic folk death metal. This release stands out as the best EP of the year, showcasing their continued excellence in blending folk elements with the intensity of death metal, and making some amazing songs.
Having followed Bloody Tyrant for quite some time, it was a pleasant surprise to see them return with a follow-up to their 2018 album. “Hagakure II” continues the legacy of its predecessor, delivering a powerful and harmonious brutal blend of styles. This EP not only meets but also elevates the expectations set by their previous work.
Best Alternative Metal Album – Bleed Out – Within Temptation
Normally, you’d find Within Temptation in the Symphonic section, but that’s not the case here. n a time where bands often adhere to established norms, setting predictable rhythms and sticking firmly to conventional trajectories, Within Temptation’s ‘Bleed Out’ emerges as an invigorating gust of fresh air. Looking into this album, we’re not just engaging with a collection of tracks; we’re witnessing the culmination of an odyssey, charting through highs, lows, and unforeseen global events.
Each track, whether it’s an earlier release or a brand-new offering, stands showcases the band’s ability to strike a chord, both musically and emotionally. There’s a delicate balance achieved between the classic Within Temptation sound we’ve grown to love and the fresh, innovative approaches they’ve embraced. They’ve given us a great reflection of the times, a response to the world around them, and a glimpse into their evolving artistic souls with this release.
Best Music Video – Sabat – Deloraine
For our video pick, we are going on the more folk side of things. Our choice for the best music video of the year is “Sabat” by Deloraine. Released in time for Samhain back in October, this video is a deep dive into the darker realms of folk, distinguished by its grand production. The video for “Sabat” is remarkable for its exceptional cinematography, making it one of the most beautifully shot and visually arresting videos we’ve encountered this year.
The video is a collaborative creation, directed by the adept trio of František Menšík, Derias, and Michal Reyza Samson. Their collective vision brings the song to life through a series of striking visual storytelling. “Sabat” stands out not just for its visual appeal, but for how it encapsulates the song’s themes in a vivid and creative manner. This music video is an example of the power of artistic synergy, merging sound and visual art into an experience that is breathtaking.
